Modern Deck Makeover With SuperDeck

September 19, 2019

Hi! I'm Nicole

Fearless DIY. Sharing building project tutorials and interior design tips. Let’s build something beautiful together. For more projects, design tips and behind the scenes, follow me @designtobuild.nicole

More About Me



Modern Deck Makeover 

A few years ago we applied Behr DeckOver to our deck. This led to nothing but problems. 🙁 Not trying to trash talk Behr products…I LOVE their paint and use it all the time. However, when it comes to this particular product, after a harsh Indiana winter, I was not a fan. 🙁 But apparently, I didn’t learn my lesson, because I had my eldest son apply another coat on the deck the following summer. I guess I thought, maybe I didn’t apply enough on the first time and second time’s a charm. Not the case…the next summer-it was all peeling off AGAIN. 🙁

So, this summer, I took a different route. After perusing my Pinterest account for a little while, I found my product…SuperDeck by Sherwin Williams. While speaking to the salesperson at Sherwin Williams, I learned that DeckOver is not a good product for the Northern states. It does great in the South, but up north here, where the temps change drastically season to season, it doesn’t hold up well. Wish I would have known that a couple summers ago. Because, now came the daunting task of having to remove all of the DeckOver. 🙁

We removed as much as we could with a power washer…

chipping and peeling paint off of a deck

The steps, leading down to the pergola, were the toughest…

paint chipping and peeling off a deck stairway

I ended up using this paint stripper product by Klean Strip. It was the only product that would even come close to removing the thick DeckOver paint. And it still came off in little sections! What a job!

Paint stripper can with spray bottle

It probably wasn’t the best thing for my health, but I felt like since I was outside, it wasn’t as bad. Still wore a little mask though. If nothing else, it made me feel a little safer…..

girl with face mask and safety goggles on

After way too much elbow grease and several days at it, we removed as much as we were going to be able to…

a deck completely stripped of paint

Finally, it was time to paint! The first color of the SuperDeck Paint was comparable to the bottom of a pool…not really the look I was going for….

deck with a blue line painted along the border

So, off to Sherwin Williams again. Only this time I played it safe and went with a color I knew…King’s Canyon. The same color we used for the body of our house this summer in our radical change-home exterior makeover. I love it up front, so why not use it on my deck makeover too!? Much better!

freshly painted gray deck

And so easy to apply! I used a roller with a long handle, after trimming out all of my edges. Definitely recommend the long handle. It will save your back! 🙂

We gave it two coats with a day of drying time in between, no foot traffic for 4 days and waited to move our furniture back 7 days. Probably much longer than necessary, but I’m really erring on the side of extra caution this time around.

Once we were able to walk on it again, I painted the trim of the windows and door, overlooking the deck, white…

2 goldendoodles sitting on a deck

Next came the best part of our deck makeover –decorating! I love this OpalHouse rug I got at Target! It was perfect for this spot….

black Opalhouse rug from Target

We did have a couple “mishaps” along the way….

When moving my farmhouse table back up onto the deck, it completely fell apart. 🙁

farmhouse table with legs broken off laying on its side on a deck with a black rug

The last 4 years of outdoor elements and moving it so many times, had loosened it up. We were hosting my family for dinner the next day, so I spent well into the wee hours of the night (with spotlights on), rebuilding and painting it. I made it to Home Depot right  before they closed to purchase a couple sawhorses. A very simple way to make a table (or fix a table 🙂 ) in a crunch.

farmhouse table on a black opalhouse rug during a deck makeover

The other frustrating thing that happened? We had our outdoor kitchen re-tiled. Which was awesome and I love it! However, I was quite irritated with the mess that the tile guy left behind. Grout all over my deck. I ended up having to scrape and repaint several areas. Definitely not happy about that. 🙁

But once we got past those two annoyances, our deck became our summer hangout spot…

outdoor kitchen with a weber grill

Got rid of our old rickety chairs and bought these metal chairs off of Amazon. I was shocked at how inexpensive they were! At that price, we ended up getting two sets…. (Amazon Affiliate Link)

deck makeover completed: outdoor table with chairs and blue umbrella

Also sent my old plastic adirondack chairs to Goodwill and built these modern comfy chairs. Super easy to build and so much less costly than the $250 (each; on sale) ones I found online at Pottery Barn. These cost me $60 for two!! Go check out that easy tutorial here. 

sideview of outdoor chairs on deck with striped blue cushions

This winter will be the real test. I’ll be sure to reference back to this post in the Spring and give a follow-up report on how well the Sherwin Williams SuperDeck Paint held up. Fingers crossed, we won’t be doing yet another deck makeover next summer!!

Be sure to Pin It to your Pinterest Board for later…

PIN IT farmhouse table and chairs on a deck

Until next time,

Happy Building, Friend!!

Be sure to join my VIP List below and never miss an upcoming post.

Other great outdoor posts:

Modern Outdoor Chairs-Easy to Build and Affordable

How to Limewash Brick Exterior-A Complete Makeover

The Cheapest Way to Make a Flower Box

How to Build Board & Batten Craftsman Shutters

Craftsman Garage Doors-Get the Look Without All the Costs




Read more posts like this one…

How Can You Make Your Home Move Easier?

How Can You Make Your Home Move Easier?

There are quite a few things that you need to do when you are buying a home. The buying process is only the start of it though, the move is a major part of buying a home. It can come with a lot of stress and be hard to tackle.  It can at times, leave you pulling your...

Easy How to Makeover Your Garage Door to a DIY Carriage Door

Easy How to Makeover Your Garage Door to a DIY Carriage Door

In the 16 years we have lived in our home, one of the best upgrades we have ever made, is our DIY carriage door update. Without the added accessories, our garage doors are very boring. Nothing whatsoever to draw the eye. But a few years back, I added a few things to...